NinjaTrader vs TradeStation: Yikuphi Okungcono

1. Inkundla Yokuhweba

Inkundla yokuhweba isoftware ewumongo ukuthi traders ukusebenzisa ukufinyelela izimakethe, ukwenza ama-oda, ukuhlaziya amashadi, nokuphatha ama-akhawunti abo. Inkundla yokuhweba enhle kufanele ithembeke, isheshe, isebenziseke kalula, futhi ingabizi. Okulandelayo yizici ezihlukanisa zombili izinkundla:

1.1. I-interface yomsebenzisi kanye nokusebenziseka kalula

Umsebenzisi obonakalayo kanye nokusebenziseka kalula kwenkundla yokuhweba kungaba nomthelela omkhulu kulwazi lokuhweba nokusebenza. I-interface yomsebenzisi eklanywe kahle kufanele ibe enembile, eyenzeka ngokwezifiso, futhi iyasabela. Kufanele futhi inikeze ukufinyelela okulula ezicini ezibaluleke kakhulu nemisebenzi yesikhulumi.

NinjaTrader:

NinjaTrader una Design modular, okusho ukuthi traders ingavula amawindi amaningi futhi iwahlele ngokuya ngokuthanda kwawo. Iwindi ngalinye lingabonisa izinhlobo ezahlukene zolwazi, njengamashadi, okufakiwe kwe-oda, abahlaziyi bemakethe, izindaba, njll. I-NinjaTrader futhi ivumela traders kuye ku- dala izindawo zokusebenza zangokwezifiso futhi uwagcine ukuze uwasebenzise esikhathini esizayo.

TradeIsiteshi:

TradeIsiteshi, ngakolunye uhlangothi, sinokuningi umklamo ohlanganisiwe, okusho traders ingafinyelela izici eziningi nemisebenzi efasiteleni elilodwa eliyinhloko. Iwindi elikhulu liqukethe amathebhu amaningana, njengamashadi, i-matrix, iskena, isikrini se-radar, njll. Ithebhu ngayinye ingabonisa izinhlobo ezahlukene zolwazi, njengamashadi, okufakiwe kwe-oda, njll. TradeIsiteshi sibuye sivumele traders kuye ku- dala izakhiwo zangokwezifiso futhi uwagcine ukuze uwasebenzise esikhathini esizayo.

Zombili izinkundla zinikeza a izinga eliphezulu lokwenza ngokwezifiso kanye nokwenza kube ngokwakho. Traders ingakwazi ukulungisa imibala, amafonti, osayizi, nokuma kwezinto ezihlukahlukene esikrinini. Bangakwazi futhi ukwengeza noma basuse amabha wamathuluzi, amamenyu, izinkinobho, nezinkomba. Nokho, abanye traders angathola uNinjaTrader evumelana nezimo futhi eguquguqukayo, kuyilapho abanye bengakhetha TradeIndlela yesiteshi elula nelula.

Zombili izinkundla nazo zine-a ijika lokufunda, ikakhulukazi kwabaqalayo. Traders badinga ukujwayelana nezici zeplathifomu ngayinye, imisebenzi, namagama. Badinga futhi ukufunda indlela yokuhamba, ukulungisa, nokusebenzisa inkundla. Zombili izinkundla zinikeza okokufundisa, amavidiyo, nemihlahlandlela ukusiza traders uqalise.

Nali ithebula elifingqa umehluko omkhulu phakathi kwe-NinjaTrader futhi TradeIsiteshi ngokuya nge-interface yomsebenzisi kanye nokusebenziseka kalula:

1.2. Amakhono Wokushaja nokwenza ngokwezifiso

I-Charting ingenye yezici ezibaluleke kakhulu zesikhulumi sokuhweba. Amashadi avumela traders kuye ku- bona ngeso lengqondo izimakethe ezahlukahlukene nokunyakaza kwamanani amathuluzi namaphethini. Amashadi nawo anika amandla traders kuye ku- isicelo analysis technical, okuwucwaningo lokuziphatha kwentengo edlule ukubikezela ukunyakaza kwentengo okuzayo namathrendi.

Bobabili NinjaTrader futhi TradeUkunikezwa kwesiteshi amakhono okushadi athuthukile nezinketho zokwenza ngokwezifiso. TradeI-rs ingakhetha ezinhlotsheni ezihlukahlukene zamashadi, njengothi lwekhandlela, ibha, umugqa, indawo, i-renko, i-heikin-ashi, njll. Bangakwazi futhi ukulungisa amafreyimu esikhathi amashadi, izikali, nezikhawu. Zombili izinkundla ziyakuvumela traders kuye ku- dala amashadi amaningi futhi uzixhume ndawonye ukuze uzishintshe kalula futhi uzivumelanise. Kodwa-ke, kunomehluko othile phakathi kwalezi zinkundla ezimbili ngokuya ngezici zokushadi nokusebenza.

NinjaTrader:

NinjaTrader unokuningi enamandla futhi evumelana nezimo injini yokudweba, evumela traders ukudala izitayela zeshadi langokwezifiso, izinkomba, kanye amasu. NinjaTrader futhi isekela isikhathi esiningi futhi ukuhlaziywa kwezinsimbi eziningi, okusho ukuthi tradeI-rs ingamboza amafreyimu esikhathi ahlukene nezinsimbi eshadini elifanayo. NinjaTrader futhi inesici esiyingqayizivele esibizwa ngokuthi ishadi Trader, evumela traders ukubeka nokuphatha ama-oda ngokuqondile eshadini.

TradeIsiteshi:

TradeIsiteshi, ngakolunye uhlangothi, sinokuningi umsebenzisi-friendly futhi enembile charting interface, evumela traders ukufinyelela nokuguqula izilungiselelo zeshadi nezinkomba kalula. TradeIsiteshi siphinde sibe nesici esibizwa ngokuthi EasyLanguage, evumela traders ukwakha izinkomba zangokwezifiso namasu usebenzisa ulimi olulula lokuhlela. Ukwengeza, inenye inzuzo ebizwa Isikrini se-Radar, evumela traders ukuqapha nokuskena izimakethe eziningi namathuluzi ngesikhathi sangempela.

Zombili izinkundla zinikeza umtapo wolwazi omkhulu we izinkomba zobuchwepheshe ezakhiwe ngaphambilini, njenge ukuhamba ngamaphesenti, ama-oscillators, imigqa yethrendi, njll. Baphinde bavumele traders ukwakha yabo izinkomba zangokwezifiso besebenzisa izilimi zabo zokuhlela ezihlukene. Nokho, abanye traders angathola uNinjaTrader eguquguqukayo futhi eqinile, kuyilapho abanye bengayithola TradeIsiteshi sifinyeleleka kalula futhi esikahle.

Nali ithebula elifingqa umehluko omkhulu phakathi kwe-NinjaTrader futhi TradeIsiteshi ngokwamakhono wokushadi nokwenza ngokwezifiso:

1.3. Izinkomba zobuchwepheshe namathuluzi okubuyisela emuva

Izinkomba zobuchwepheshe izibalo zezibalo ezisetshenziswa enanini nakudatha yevolumu yemakethe noma ithuluzi. Izinkomba zobuchwepheshe ziyasiza traders ukuhlonza izitayela, amaphethini, amasignali, namathuba emakethe. Izinkomba zobuchwepheshe zingahlukaniswa ngezigaba ezahlukene, njengethrendi, umfutho, ukungazami, ivolumu, njll.

Ukubuyela emuva inqubo ye ukuhlola isu lokuhweba noma isistimu kudatha yomlando ukuze ihlole ukusebenza kwayo kanye nenzuzo. Ukuhlehla kuyasiza traders ukuthuthukisa, ukucwenga, kanye nokuqinisekisa imibono yabo yokuhweba kanye nokuqagela. Ukuhlola imuva nakho kungasiza traders igwema ukucwiliswa ngokweqile, ukufaka ijika, nokuchema nokumbiwa kwedatha.

Bobabili NinjaTrader futhi TradeUkunikezwa kwesiteshi anhlobonhlobo izinkomba zobuchwepheshe namathuluzi okubuyisela emuva. TradeI-rs ingakhetha kumakhulu ezinkomba ezakhelwe ngaphambilini ezitholakala endaweni ngayinye. Bangakwazi futhi ukudala ezabo izinkomba zangokwezifiso besebenzisa izilimi zabo zokuhlela ezihlukene. Zombili izinkundla ziyakuvumela traders ukusebenzisa izinkomba eziningi eshadini elifanayo futhi ulungise amapharamitha azo nezilungiselelo. Nokho, kukhona umehluko phakathi kwamapulatifomu amabili ngokwezinkomba zobuchwepheshe namathuluzi okubuyisela emuva.

NinjaTrader:

NinjaTrader unokuningi injini yokubuyisela emuva ethuthukile futhi eyinkimbinkimbi, evumela traders ukwenza ukulinganisa komlando, ukuhamba phambili, kanye ne-Monte Carlo. NinjaTrader futhi isekela ufuzo kanye nokwenza kahle kwezinhloso eziningi, okusho ukuthi traders angathola inhlanganisela efanele yamapharamitha nezinjongo zamasu awo. NinjaTrader futhi inesici esibizwa Isu Analyzer, evumela traders ukuhlaziya nokuqhathanisa ukusebenza nezibalo zamasu abo.

TradeIsiteshi:

TradeIsiteshi, ngakolunye uhlangothi, sinokuningi isikhombimsebenzisi esilula nesiqondile sokubuyisela emuva, evumela traders ukwenza ukuhlolwa komlando nokuya phambili. TradeIsiteshi sibuye sisekele ukufeza inhloso eyodwa, okusho ukuthi traders angathola inani eliphelele lepharamitha eyodwa noma umgomo wamasu awo. TradeIsiteshi siphinde sibe nesici esibizwa ngokuthi Umbiko Wokusebenza Kwesu, evumela traders ukubuka nokuthekelisa ukusebenza kanye nezibalo zamasu abo.

Nali ithebula elifingqa umehluko omkhulu phakathi kwe-NinjaTrader futhi TradeIsiteshi ngokuya ngezinkomba zobuchwepheshe namathuluzi okubuyisela emuva:

1.4. Isivinini Sokwenziwa Kwe-oda Nokwethenjelwa

Isivinini sokwenza i-oda nokwethembeka yizici ezibalulekile ekusebenzeni traders ngubani trade njalo futhi ngamavolumu amakhulu. Isivinini sokwenza i-oda sibhekise ku ukuthi inkundla yokuhweba ingathumela, yamukele, futhi ikhiphe ama-oda ngokushesha kangakanani emakethe. Ukuthembeka kokwenziwa kwe-oda kubhekise ku ukuthi isiteji sokuhweba esingaguquguquki futhi sinembile kanjani singenza ama-oda Ngokusho kwe trader imiyalelo kanye nokulindelwe.

Bobabili NinjaTrader futhi TradeIsiteshi sinikezela ngamakhono wokwenza i-oda asheshayo nathembekile. TradeI-rs ingakhetha ezinhlotsheni ezihlukene ze-oda, njengemakethe, umkhawulo, isitobhi, umkhawulo wokuma, isitobhi esilandelanayo, njll. Nokho, kunomehluko othile phakathi kwezinkundla ezimbili ngokuya ngesivinini sokwenza i-oda nokwethembeka.

NinjaTrader:

NinjaTrader una uhlelo lokuhleleka oluqondile nolusebenza ngempumelelo, evumela traders ukuxhuma kokuningi brokers nabahlinzeki bedatha. NinjaTrader futhi isekela ukuphathwa kwe-oda ohlangothini lweseva, okusho ukuthi ama-oda agcinwa futhi asetshenziswe ku- brokeriseva esikhundleni se- trader ikhompuyutha. Lokhu kunciphisa i ingozi yokuhluleka kwe-oda ngenxa yezinkinga zenethiwekhi noma zehadiwe.

TradeIsiteshi:

TradeIsiteshi, ngakolunye uhlangothi, sine- uhlelo lokuhleleka okuthe xaxa nolwendawo eyodwa, okusho ukuthi traders kufanele usebenzise TradeIsiteshi njengesabo broker kanye nomhlinzeki wedatha. Iphinde isekele ukuphathwa kwe-oda ohlangothini lweklayenti, okusho ukuthi ama-oda agcinwa futhi asetshenziswe ku- trader’s kukhompuyutha hhayi ku- brokeriseva. Lokhu kwandisa ukuncika nokuba sengozini kwe- trader uhlelo.

Nali ithebula elifingqa umehluko omkhulu phakathi kwe-NinjaTrader futhi TradeIsiteshi ngokuya ngesivinini sokwenza i-oda nokuthembeka:

1.5. Ukuhweba Kwamaphepha Nezici Zokulingisa

Ukuhweba kwamaphepha kanye nokulingiswa kuvumela traders kuye ku- trade ngemali ebonakalayo kanye nezimo zemakethe ezilingisayo ngenkathi usebenzisa izici ezifanayo kanye nemisebenzi yesikhulumi sokuhweba.

Bobabili NinjaTrader futhi TradeIsiteshi sinikeza ukuhweba ngephepha nezici zokulingisa. Traders bangakha futhi basebenzise ama-akhawunti okuhweba amaphepha ahlukene nama-akhawunti abo okuhweba bukhoma. Kodwa-ke, kunomehluko othile phakathi kwamapulatifomu amabili ngokuya ngokuhweba kwephepha nezici zokulingisa.

NinjaTrader:

NinjaTrader una injini yokulingisa enengqondo futhi ebanzi, evumela traders ukulingisa izimo zemakethe ezahlukahlukene, njengokushelela, amakhomishini, ukubambezeleka, njll. NinjaTrader futhi isekela dlala kabusha imodi, evumela traders ukudlala kabusha idatha yemakethe yomlando kanye trade sengathi ibukhoma. NinjaTrader futhi inesici esibizwa Ukudlala kabusha kwemakethe, evumela traders ukulanda futhi udlale futhi idatha yemakethe evela ezinhlobonhlobo brokers nabahlinzeki bedatha.

TradeIsiteshi:

TradeIsiteshi, ngakolunye uhlangothi, sine- injini yokulingisa eyisisekelo futhi enomkhawulo, engabaleli ezinye izici zemakethe, njengokushelela, amakhomishini, ukubambezeleka, njll. TradeIsiteshi futhi asisekeli imodi yokudlala futhi, okusho ukuthi traders kuphela trade ngedatha yemakethe yesikhathi sangempela noma ebambezelekile. TradeIsiteshi naso asinaso isici esifana ne-Market Replay, okusho ukuthi traders angasebenzisa kuphela idatha yemakethe ehlinzekwe ngu TradeIsiteshi.

Nali ithebula elifingqa umehluko omkhulu phakathi kwe-NinjaTrader futhi TradeIsiteshi ngokuya ngokuhweba kwephepha nezici zokulingisa:

2. Amakilasi Empahla Nezimakethe

Izigaba zempahla nezimakethe yizona izinhlobo zamathuluzi ezezimali nokuhwebelana ukuthi traders ingakwazi trade endaweni yokuhweba. Izigaba zempahla nezimakethe zinezici ezihlukile, njenge izimali, i-volatility, amandla, wekhasi, Njll

Bobabili NinjaTrader futhi TradeIsiteshi sinikeza ukufinyelela ezinhlobonhlobo zezigaba zempahla nezimakethe. Traders ingakwazi trade ikakhulukazi ikusasa, izinketho, kanye forex kuzo zombili izinkundla. Nokho, kunomehluko othile phakathi kwalezi zinkundla ezimbili ngokwezigaba zempahla nezimakethe.

NinjaTrader:

NinjaTrader una isiteji esivumelana nezimo futhi esivulekile, evumela traders ukuxhuma kokuningi brokers nabahlinzeki bedatha. NinjaTrader futhi isekela ukuhweba kwe ikusasa elincane, okuyizinkontileka ezincane ezidinga imali encane kanye nobungozi. Ipulatifomu nayo ine- Isici se-SuperDOM, evumela traders ukubuka futhi trade ukujula kwemakethe yethuluzi kanye nebhuku loku-oda.

TradeIsiteshi:

TradeIsiteshi, ngakolunye uhlangothi, sine inkundla evaliwe, okusho ukuthi traders kufanele usebenzise TradeIsiteshi njengesabo broker kanye nomhlinzeki wedatha. TradeIsiteshi futhi asikusekeli ukuhweba kwama-micro futures, okusho ukuthi traders kufanele trade izinkontileka ezijwayelekile ezidinga imali eyengeziwe nobungozi. Nokho, inesici esibizwa Matrix, evumela traders ukubuka futhi trade ukujula kwemakethe kanye nebhuku loku-oda lanoma iyiphi ithuluzi.

Nali ithebula elifingqa umehluko omkhulu phakathi kwe-NinjaTrader futhi TradeIsiteshi ngokuya ngamakilasi ezimpahla nezimakethe:

3. Izimali kanye namaKhomishini

Izimali ezikhokhwayo kanye namakhomishini yizona izindleko ukuthi traders kufanele ukhokhe ukuze usebenzise inkundla yokuhweba futhi ufinyelele izimakethe. Izimali ezikhokhwayo namakhomishana zingaba nomthelela omkhulu ekwenzeni inzuzo nokusebenza kwe traders, ikakhulukazi esebenzayo traders ngubani trade njalo futhi ngamavolumu amakhulu.

Bobabili NinjaTrader futhi TradeIzimali ezikhokhiswa esiteshini namakhomishini ngamasevisi nemikhiqizo yazo. Traders kufanele akhokhe amakhomishini okuhweba ngayinye trade bahlabela emsamo. Kodwa-ke, kunomehluko othile phakathi kwamapulatifomu amabili ngokuya ngezimali namakhomishini.

NinjaTrader:

NinjaTrader una enokuncintisana futhi esobala ukwakheka kwentengo, okuvumela traders ukukhetha ezinhlelweni zekhomishini ezahlukene kanye nezinketho zamanani. NinjaTrader futhi inikeza ilayisense yamahhala yokuphila konke yesikhulumi sayo, incazelo traders angayisebenzisa ngaphandle kokukhokha noma yiziphi izimali zenkundla. Ngaphezu kwalokho, ihlinzeka futhi khulula real-time futhi imakethe yomlando idatha yezigaba ezithile zempahla nezimakethe.

TradeIsiteshi:

TradeIsiteshi, ngakolunye uhlangothi, sinokuningi isakhiwo samanani esiyinkimbinkimbi nesiguquguqukayo, okuncike ohlotsheni lwe-akhawunti, isigaba sempahla, imakethe, nomsebenzi wokuhweba. TradeIsiteshi futhi ukhokhisa imali yesikhulumi ngokusebenzisa inkundla yayo, engayekwa noma yehliswe kuye ngevolumu yokuhweba kanye nebhalansi ye-akhawunti.

Nali ithebula elifingqa umehluko omkhulu phakathi kwe-NinjaTrader futhi TradeIsiteshi ngokwezinkokhelo namakhomishini:

4. Ucwaningo Nezemfundo

Ucwaningo kanye imfundo izici ezibalulekile ze traders abafuna ukuhlala benolwazi lwakamuva futhi benolwazi mayelana nezimakethe nentuthuko. Kuyasiza traders ukufunda amakhono amasha namasu futhi bathuthukise ukusebenza kwabo kokuhweba kanye nemiphumela.

Bobabili NinjaTrader futhi TradeIsiteshi sinikeza ucwaningo nezici zemfundo. Traders angakwazi ukufinyelela futhi asebenzise amathuluzi okucwaninga ahlukahlukene kanye nezinsiza ezitholakala endaweni ngayinye. Bangakwazi futhi ukubamba iqhaza futhi bafunde kuma-webinars, okokufundisa, nokuqukethwe okufundisayo okunikezwa inkundla ngayinye. Kodwa-ke, kunomehluko othile phakathi kwalezi zinkundla zombili mayelana nezici zocwaningo nezici zemfundo.

NinjaTrader:

NinjaTrader unokuningi igxile futhi ikhethekile ucwaningo kanye nenkundla yezemfundo egxile kakhulu ekusaseni kanye forex ukuhweba. NinjaTrader futhi inesici esibizwa I-NinjaScript, evumela traders ukudala izinkomba zangokwezifiso, amasu, nezengezo kusetshenziswa ulimi lokuhlela olususelwe ku-C#. Iphinde ibe nesici esibizwa ngokuthi NinjaTrader I-Ecosystem, okuyinethiwekhi yonjiniyela bezinkampani zangaphandle, othisha, nabeluleki.

TradeIsiteshi:

TradeIsiteshi, ngakolunye uhlangothi, sine- inkundla yocwaningo nemfundo ebanzi futhi ehlukahlukene, ehlanganisa amakilasi ezimpahla ahlukahlukene nezimakethe. TradeIsiteshi siphinde sibe nesici esibizwa ngokuthi EasyLanguage, evumela traders ukwakha izinkomba namasu angokwezifiso. Iphinde ibe nesinye isici esibizwa ngokuthi TradeStation Inyuvesi, okuyisikhungo sokufunda esiku-inthanethi esihlinzeka ngezifundo, amavidiyo, izindatshana, nemicimbi.

Nali ithebula elifingqa umehluko omkhulu phakathi kwe-NinjaTrader futhi TradeIsiteshi ngokuya ngocwaningo nezici zemfundo:

5. Umphakathi kanye Nokwesekwa

Umphakathi nokwesekwa nakho kuyasiza traders ukuxazulula noma yiziphi izinkinga noma izinkinga abangase bahlangabezane nazo ngenkathi besebenzisa inkundla yokuhweba. Ingahlukaniswa ngezigaba ezihlukene, njengezinkundla zabasebenzisi, ukusekelwa komphakathi, isevisi yamakhasimende, nolwazi lwabasebenzisi.

Bobabili NinjaTrader futhi TradeIsiteshi sinikeza umphakathi kanye nezici zokusekela. Traders angakwazi ukufinyelela futhi ajoyine izinkundla ezihlukahlukene zabasebenzisi nemiphakathi etholakala endaweni ngayinye. Bangakwazi futhi ukuthola futhi banikeze ukwesekwa komphakathi kanye nempendulo evela kwabanye traders kanye nochwepheshe. Kodwa-ke, kunomehluko phakathi kwalezi zingxenyekazi zombili mayelana nezici zomphakathi nezici zokusekela.

NinjaTrader:

NinjaTrader ine-esebenzayo futhi ewusizo kakhulu umsebenzisi forum kanye nomphakathi, eyenganyelwe futhi isekelwe yi-Ninja esemthethweniTradeithimba lokusekela. Futhi uthola ukufinyelela ku- Iforamu yokusekela, okuyinkundla ezinikele yabasebenzisi ukuthi babuze futhi baphendule imibuzo, babike futhi baxazulule izinkinga, futhi bacele futhi baphakamise izici.

TradeIsiteshi:

TradeIsiteshi, ngakolunye uhlangothi, sinokuningi inkundla yomsebenzisi engenzi lutho futhi enomkhawulo kanye nomphakathi, engenganyelwe noma engasekelwe ithimba labasekeli elisemthethweni. TradeIsiteshi asinikezi izici ezifana ne-NinjaTrader Iforamu Yokusekela noma i-NinjaTrader Ecosystem, okusho ukuthi abasebenzisi kufanele baseshe futhi bathole imikhiqizo namasevisi ezinkampani zangaphandle TradeAbasebenzisi besiteshi.

Nali ithebula elifingqa umehluko omkhulu phakathi kwe-NinjaTrader futhi TradeIsiteshi ngokomphakathi nezici zosekelo: